Show Idle (> d.) Chans


← | Results 590501 ... 590750 found in trilema for 'the' | →

fractal: i can get them if needed tho
fractal: jborkl: I asked mircea_popescu this question , in the logs he said he'd like to see proof of a 400Gh unit as well as a 25Gh unit ... i dont have logs tho
fractal: jurov: it's not just 400Gh being shipped --- its 400Gh in a single unit as advertised -- if they ship more hardware to make it up for it -- its because performance wasn't met
jborkl: I think the 5 25 would be sufficient
jurov: now the question is, whether we require proof of one 400gh order filled, too
jborkl: jurov: I would think reading it first order of business is the 5 delivery, as you were looking at
fractal: Anduck: according to the wording its totally not fair for 2 M-boards or multiple hardware considered a 400gh 'unit' since the company advertised a 400Gh unit as "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"" --- to be honest -- the vagureness of the langugage makes it unfair for either side to win or lose --
mircea_popescu: since motherfuckin server is still diddling ;/
mircea_popescu: fractal Anduck http://pastebin.com/JgudvNWW that's a paste of the article.
Anduck: there are most likely going to be 5 deliveries of the 25gh units
jurov: jborkl, only the 25ghs
jborkl: have there been 5 deliveries of either of the units?
fractal: Anduck: I'm in for nearly that on the NO side...
Anduck: the same that were shipped to me
Anduck: there actually was weeks ago a 400gh rig built from these h-boards
jurov: when has not happened either
Anduck: i made the 10btc bet
fractal: the other thing i'm worried about is punin sending pictures to a forum user and paying them to post a 400Gh unit saying its hashing at 400Gh -- rumour has it punin made the 10BTC yes bet
Anduck: since it's proven that 400gh unit will meet the spec
jurov: and thus any bickering about what hardware the 400gh means is noot
Anduck: but there might be shipped 400 gh units.
Anduck: jurov: yeah there isn't any delivered yet
fractal: I only made the bet based on what I say on the bitfury website -- that a 400Gh unit was "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
jurov: and now i want to know whether *any* 400gh order was fullfilled
fractal: jurov: i dont disagree -- but not according to the bet langugae
fractal: its right on their website -- 400Gh mining unit "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
Anduck: the mining unit can include anything
Anduck: i think unit is the mining unit.
fractal: No, you weren't -- not according to the bet langugage -- which is what matters
Anduck: the bet was about that
Anduck: they deliver the promised performance. that's it
Anduck: and is there a fee or something for that
Anduck: mircea_popescu: can the bets be canceled, then?
jurov: because if someone ordered and did not get it yet, then bet is false
jurov: so, i prefer to ask whether anyone actually ordered that product (regardless of actual HW)
fractal: Anduck: to be honest -- i'd rather cancel the bet then have a long forum discussion that takes hours of debate over the next few days -- if you'd agree... otherwise I'll have to clear my schedule ;)
fractal: jurov: thats just good customer support -- but doesn't make the fact that the 400Gh miner isn't 400Gh any different --- and thats what the bet language is about
jurov: then that's an unit, imho... but as nothing such was actually delivered, it's undecidable
Anduck: doesn't matter how many m-boards or h-boards are needed for the performance of the mining unit
Anduck: the mining kit promised performance is met
fractal: Anduck: that's irrelevant to the bet language
Anduck: everyone gets the hashrate they paid for. and the hashrate will be made within the power usage promised
fractal: jurov: there needs to be a 400Gh UNIT -- which doesn't exist
fractal: jurov: they're compensating. and thats great... But the bet doesn't say that
jborkl: jurov: they are shipping 400gh that draws 350w
Anduck: jurov: you pay for the 400 gh and you get the 400 gh
jurov: then it would *not* meet expected perf
jurov: Anduck: if you bought 400gh for some amount of money and then you'd found out you have to buy more hardware to get 400gh
fractal: Anduck: The best doesn't say 'If the 400Gh miner only mines at 380Gh' they can ship more hardware and its a yes
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the bet says
Anduck: fractal: that was the advertised hardware... the bet wasn't about advertised hardware. it was about advertised performance. 400gh for 400 watts. people ordered a kit which produces that and they get what they ordered
jurov: the bet. i mean
jurov: i think if they don't ship more boards as a kit to fullfill the 400gh, then it's clearly false
mircea_popescu: mpoe-pr "lol yknow eventually there's gonna bet a channel dedicated to debating bitbet wording"
fractal: mircea_popescu: no, i'm not..... can both sides agree to cancel the bet?
Anduck: fractal: they didn't meet the advertised hardware amount. but they meet the advertised performance by far!!
fractal: they are sold with 1 M-board
Anduck: the bet wasn't about the amount of hardware delivered... it was about the kits/units and thheir performance
jurov: so, are the kits with multiple h-boards actually sold?
fractal: Anduck: That's not what the language in the bet says though.... seriously... I'm sorry you weren't more specific
Anduck: the bet was about the advertised performance, that be 400gh unit will produce 400gh and it will do it for less than the 400 watts
fractal: jurov: Anduck's argument is that if they send more hardware for free then it counts as being part of the same device
Anduck: jurov: full kits include more h-boards because of the performance problems with h-boards. but the unit of 400ghash is 400ghash, dependless of the amount of h-boards in the unit/kit/miner
jurov: but they aren't 400gh yet
fractal: jurov: " Bitfury 400 GH/s Miner – currently hashing at 380 GH/s on 16 cards. " -- thats correct -- punin admitted it missed hashrate specs -- they will fix it in next manufacturing batch, but its impossible to do that and ship by sept 1---
Anduck: jurov: the units/kits will be hashing the promised hashrate
jurov: "Full kits include a main board, 16 hashing boards, a raspberry pi, and cables to set up the miner."
ozbot: Bitfury 400 GH/s Bitcoin Mining Rig Hits US Shores - The Genesis Block
jurov: http://thegenesisblock.com/bitfury-400-ghs-bitcoin-mining-rig-hits-us-shores/ interprets it so that "the miner gives only 380GH/s"
ozbot: imgur: the simple image sharer
Anduck: it's only about the advertised performance, 400 ghash miner for 400 warrs
fractal: I went to bitfurystrikesback.com and looked at what was advertised -- I thought, no way they'll get 400Gh on that M-board with 16 cards -- they might hit power -- but I don't think they'll get 400Gh out of that --- I put my money where my mouth is, and I was right--
Anduck: nor the hardware
mircea_popescu: in retrospect i think this is absolutely the first time a genuine wording problem has come to fore. the previous one (on the bfl specs) was thoroughly manufactured by dishonest blf.
Anduck: jurov: people ordered 25gh unit (was meant to be 1 h-board + 1 m-board) but they were delivered 1 m-board and 2 h-boards instead.. for the same price. that was because the performance of the single h-board didn't meet the 25ghash -> they had to add another 25gh board in the kit)
Anduck: fractal: i don't see why.. the performance is met and it can be proven from the hashrate@power usage of the smaller hashrate miners
fractal: jborkl: Its not irrelvant since its in the bet.... UNIT means a single device
jurov: for the same price?
jurov: or they did order and got 2 boxes instead?
jborkl: the word "units" in the bet is irrevelvant
Anduck: mircea_popescu: the thing bfsb sold
Anduck: mircea_popescu: will there be needed a 400 gh unit delivered?
fractal: Anduck: No, punin said they need to change hardware and it will be done on the next batch -- but not before september 1
mircea_popescu: jborkl that's the stated intention. nobody has yet come forward having received a 400gh order
Anduck: mircea_popescu: it doesn't really matter since the customers get what they were promised. and in the future they might be able to turn their miners for even powerful miners with software update
jborkl: they bet is a yes then
fractal: jborkl: yes, but thats not what the language of the bet said.
Anduck: the performance of the h-boards itself will be most likely fixed by software, still
jborkl: and they are going to provie customers with 400 gh as promised for the 350w draw?
fractal: Anduck: they can't fit 20h-boards on a 400gh unit..... a 400gh unit can fix 16h-cards maximum.... hence UNIT
Anduck: mircea_popescu: theyre underhashing most likely due to the quality of the fab and software
Anduck: if bfsb shipped 20 h-boards for the 400gh unit, it would draw only 360 watts. and it'd provide 400gh
fractal: jborkl: There is no 400Gh device....
mircea_popescu: why are they underhashing anyway ? any word from manufacturer ?
johnnyfootball: get with the program
fractal: Anduck: That is not what was advertised. What was advertised was not met. 400Gh was not achived with the hardware, so they had to re-imburse customers at their own expense --- I knew they would miss these targets, which is why i bet NO
Anduck: atleast my 68 ghash at 53 W _from the wall_
kleeck: I think there's only one solution to this. Duel to the death!
Anduck: the 400gh miner performs 400 gh at the promised watts.
Anduck: and as the 400 gh units are built from same h-boards as 25 gh units, it's clear that 400 gh @ 400 watt performance is met like the 25gh @ 40W is met
fractal: Anduck: No, performance is not met. The 400Gh miner does not perform 400Gh.
Anduck: the units that customers get do have the performance of 25gh at 40 watts max
Anduck: the performance is met.. performance of the unit: hashrate @ power usage
fractal: Anduck: they are shipping additional hardware because performance was NOT met
fractal: Anduck: thats why they're shipping additional hardware. Why would they send more hardware then promised if performance is met? They woudln't.
Anduck: and the performance is absolutely met
Anduck: fractal: wasn't about advertised hardware... it was about the performance
fractal: Anduck: for the bet to be yes, "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" has to exist -- and it doesn't
Anduck: well mircea_popescu.. wasn't that kinda clear? if there's no cap of s.dice at mpex, it's same as zero cap
fractal: Anduck: and the 400Gh miner includes 16 H-bords -- AS ADVERTISED
Anduck: they missed specs of the h-board but not the kit/unit/miner
fractal: They have to ship additional hardware SPECIFICALLY Because they missed advertised specs
fractal: Anduck: No, they didn't the units don't hit 400Gh as advertised --
Anduck: the units that were sold, they were 25gh unit and 400gh unit
Anduck: fractal: they didn't deliver the promised hardware, yes. but they delivered the promised performance of the units
Anduck: mircea_popescu: when s.dice dropped out of MPEX, the value was considered zero?
fractal: They weren't able to deliver this
fractal: UNIT. as in what was advertised -- From the website " What’s included: 1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
Anduck: mircea_popescu: that log you linked is about the s.dice vs s.mpoe bet?
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the English on the bet says. It says the 400 Gh 'UNIT'
kleeck: Does bitbet need an arbiter of justice? I'd love that role... also the title.
Anduck: fractal: the bet was about promised performance, not about promised hardware
mircea_popescu: kleeck there's also a very lulzy one on the forum and here from back in march. some guy named rikur and some other guy
fractal: From the website " What’s included: 1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
mircea_popescu: anyway, for the lovers of history, here's a recent previous dispute http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=03-08-2013&display=show#202828
fractal: Anduck: not according to the language of the bet.
Anduck: the promised performance of the customer-bought kits must be met¨
Anduck: fractal: they can ship as much h-boards as they want but the PERFORMANCE must be met
fractal: UNIT.... not 'oh we ship as much hardware to make up for it if the manufacturer misses specs'
Anduck: it's very clear it means the promised miner ( a kit or a unit)
Anduck: the unit is the same thing as a kit
fractal: Anduck: No its not met.. punin admits they are under-hashing
Anduck: if he shipped GPU's, the performance (400 gh @ 400 watts) wouldn't be met
fractal: Anduck: I dont see any mention of KIT on there. And If i read the language the performance is not met in a device.
Anduck: the performance must be met. and it is met
Anduck: we're talking about kits as units anyway since they never sold single units. they're KITS
fractal: Anduck: Not according to the language though...
Anduck: fractal: he's allowed to ship as much h-boards and m-boards needed to get the performance. it wouldn't break the bet.... if they would eat more watts than promised, that would be a bet-breaker
fractal: mircea_popescu: becaucause he could ship as much hardware to make up for it -- provided the power usage was low enough.... but I placed the bet based on Power usage AND hashrate in a single self-contained UNIT
kleeck: and they have to be a "mining unit" and they have to hash at the given rates and draw at the given powers.
fractal: you removed the word UNIT didn't you??? very sneaky!
Anduck: they must meet the advertised performance (25gh @ 40W and 400gh @ 400W)
fractal: Anduck: If the bet language said "If punin can't make a 400Gh single device, he's allow to ship as much hardware as he wan'ts, and we'll just consider it a 'KIT' "" --- if it said that, there's no way in my right mind i would have bet NO... it would be an impossible bet to win
Anduck: they must be delivered this month
kleeck: There are multiple clauses in the bet that must be true for it to be "YES".
Anduck: well the bet is about performance, not the amount of h-boards used to produce the performance of the unit
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the bet says
Anduck: well the customers were promised 400 gh miner.............
fractal: Anduck: No, its not. The bet says nothing of a KIT. it says a mining unit. Somehing that is a single prodcut attacted..... 2 seperate products adding up to more then 400Gh mean that the manufacturer missed performance spec for that unit
mircea_popescu: it wasn't the case they shipped MORe units.
Anduck: customers ordered 400 gh mining kits.. and they got what were promised
kleeck: The Honorable Judge Kleeck Presiding!
Anduck: there was and never could've been a single card producing 400 ghash, it was sold as a "h-cards enough to make 400 ghash unit". RIGHT?
fractal: kleeck: If it's multiple mining units, then Anduck is not correct..
kleeck: Yes. What I'm seeing is the classic, "Oh come on, we all knew the intended bet!" Which isn't a sound defense. The debate must center around the words used to describe the bet. If the product is a "mining unit" and meets the spec in the bet, then Anduck is correct, else fractal is correct.
fractal: Anduck: Again, the language of the bet doesn't match up with the fact that performance was missed on the 25Gh board,,, the fact that they got more or were satisfied is irrelevant
Anduck: the -performance- promised to customers is met. customers get exactly the performance they ordered.
mircea_popescu: fractal also why i asked you if it's your first time and advised you go small. these things do happen.
Anduck: but the UNIT does!!!
fractal: Anduck: Sorry, the language doesn't say 'KIT'
Anduck: fractal: the 25gh unit is a 25gh kit as sold for customers, doesn't say it must include 1 h-board.
fractal: Anduck: The performance requirement was *not* met. No single H-card operates at 25Gh!
mircea_popescu: the attempt to make the context entirely explicit is burdensome and provably doomed.
mircea_popescu: human language is not meaningful unless the receptor supplies context to make it meaningful. the contexts receptors supply often vary.
kleeck: mircea_popescu, I rather enjoy what is coming of it.
fractal: mircea_popescu: right.... but in fairness, the bet doesn't say that the manufactuere can miss hashrate performance on a single 25Gh board, and ship more to make up for it!
Anduck: the statement is super clear in my eyes, really. people get what they ordered. people get the hashrate at the watts they were promised. the performance requirement (which the bet was about) IS met.
mircea_popescu: kleeck bitbet is a fascinating exercise in the limits of communication.
mircea_popescu: fractal in fairness, the "self contained device" part is also not in the bet text.
Anduck: fractal: then you tried to work the semantics against the statement of the bet or what?
fractal: Anduck: well I only placed a no bet based on the language of a UNIT being a self-containted device that is attached....
Anduck: and as customers weren't sold specifically 1 or 16 h-boards, the kits can include any amount of those.. the kits must meet the promised performance and they seem to do so
kleeck: TomServo, no, that isn't the question.
mircea_popescu: Aug 27 17:25:58 <fractal>is the bet yes or no?
mircea_popescu: Aug 27 17:25:45 <fractal>what if they ship 2 units to make up for lower hashrates?
TomServo: Isn't that the question?
TomServo: I don't understand the debate over kit, unit, whateverthefuck. Does the 'thing' do 400GH/s @ 400W or not?
mircea_popescu: <fractal> Anduck: I came in here specifically to ask mircea_popescu and he said that a 400Gh 'UNIT' must exist --- based on the math, it can't <<< which snippet is this ?
fractal: Anduck: you can't make a vague bet, and then claim 'semantics' when you lose
fractal: Anduck: thats not what the bet language says.
fractal: Anduck: not on a single unit -- as the language says in the bet
kleeck: Are the assembled kits meeting spec once made into a mining unit?
Anduck: there can be (and will be) enough h-boards so the 400gh kit does 400 ghash
fractal: Anduck: I only placed a NO bet because I didn't belive they'd hit 400Gh in a single unit. BFL missed, and others. The bet says that there should be a 400Gh unit shipped, and it should be under 400W.... it might be under 400W, but its not 400Gh
Anduck: no need for 16 h-boards in the 400gh kit
fractal: Anduck: 68 /3 = 22.... 22*16 = 352Gh maximum in a single 'Miner', or selft contained 'unit' or 'kit..... This does not exist because the manufactuere missed performance specs.... The bet says nothing of customer relations by refunding or sending more hardware
kleeck: So, they are getting kits instead of completed devices and those devices are meeting spec?
Anduck: and the customers are getting delivered those performances
kleeck: Is the debate around the phrase, "mining units"?
Anduck: but that is the statement, isn't it??
fractal: Anduck: Sorry, again, thats not what the bet language says
Anduck: that doesn't mean it doesn't meet the performance promise of the kit/unit
Anduck: they just said that the kit will include more h-boards than it was meant to
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the bet language says
Anduck: they ship what they promised
Anduck: fractal: they sell kits, not units
fractal: Anduck: Shipping additonal hardware because the company missed spec does not mean that there is a 400Gh UNIT
Anduck: i have 3 h-boards.. they eat 54 watts from the wall
kleeck: I haven't read it yet. I will if you want. I was chiming in more to the point of "do semantics matter" - I'll read the bet.
mircea_popescu: otherwise any statement can be elongated ad infinitum with requests for definitions
fractal: Anduck: I came in here specifically to ask mircea_popescu and he said that a 400Gh 'UNIT' must exist --- based on the math, it can't
mircea_popescu: kleeck the problem is that you only have clear communication in retrospect.
Anduck: kleeck: what do you think, what's clearer way to understand the statement of the bet?
Anduck: i think the statement is more importnat
kleeck: I disagree mircea_popescu. I understand that there are situations, like this one, but there are ways of being more clear and less clear. Therefore clearity exists even if on a spectrum..
fractal: Anduck: The language on the bet says it can't.
Anduck: they dont sell units or devices, they sell kits
fractal: Anduck, i'm not done posting picture.... http://imageshack.us/a/img11/6249/krlv.png see inside the case? the M-board. it only fits 16 cards.
Anduck: i mean, the case in that picture*
Anduck: that picture is not bfsb.com product. the customer made it himself
kleeck: Yes. The "edge" is in clearly communicating. :)
Anduck: fractal: that case is not part of the bet nor is that case in the bfsb.com shop
mircea_popescu: kleeck there's always going to be some edge. natural language is what it is.
fractal: Anduck: You are spreading misinformation... there is a specific 400Ghash miner -- look at this picture. http://imageshack.us/a/img407/6741/1bzj.png
Anduck: but it is, fractal. they sell KITS
kleeck: In my experience, the wording is always important. It frames the expectation of any given interaction.
Anduck: they didnt sell units or devices
Anduck: fractal: but everyone knows that a device or unit means a kit since they only sold kits
Anduck: all the units and devices shouldve been "kit" so there wouldn't be this semantics mess
Anduck: the statement is absolotely clear in my eyes, except there should've been better words
fractal: Anduck: The word 'KIT' is totally non-existant in the bet languge
fractal: err, the statement i mean
fractal: Anduck: yes. What the bet actaully SAYS matters more then statement -- I specifically came in here 2 days ago to ask mircea_popescu specifics about this
kleeck: Don't the words comprise the bet?
Anduck: kleeck: i am asking that is the actual wording/semantics more important than the bet itself
fractal: Anduck: Which means there needs to be a 400Gh unit delivered that provides 400Gh in a single 'DEVICE', or 'UNIT' as per language in the bet.... punin has stated that they are shipping additional hardware "(until we have boards and software that delivers 25GH)" --- 16H-cards less then 25Gh means they failed to produce a 400Gh unit
Anduck: if the _bet_ itself is a clear thing how it should be understood
Anduck: mircea_popescu: just a question, how much do the semantics affect the bet outcome?
mircea_popescu: well the best i can do for either side atm is to say we'll see how this turns out.
Anduck: but that was exact quote from the bet... i'll stop fighting with you now :I
fractal: Anduck: again, thats not what the bet says. I'm very sorry.
Anduck: it's only semantics after the real deal: [20:33:31] <Anduck> the "promised performance" means that customers will get the hashing rate they ordered at the energy cost they were told it will eat
fractal: Anduck: sorry, be more carfeful next time when you read the bet statement.
Anduck: the "promised performance" means that customers will get the hashing rate they ordered at the energy cost they were told it will eat
fractal: Anduck: no they weren't. no 400Gh unit exists as per punin's admission --- also, thats not what the statement says.
Anduck: and the bet was about that
Anduck: the customer promises _are_ met 100%
fractal: Anduck: which means the bet is a NO.
fractal: Anduck: sorry for you, but the language in the statement disagrees with you.
Anduck: well it's only semantics after that. Customers got what they were promised.
Anduck: i also do not see it as a requirement that someone from the 5 confirmed deliveries must have ordered exactly 400 ghash kit
Anduck: 400 ghash kit is built from the h-boards that are used in the 25gh kit, too
Anduck: dude fractal... "Devices must meet advertised performance (25 GH/s unit 40W, 400 GH/s unit 400W)" < as you can see, the condition is in the ( and ). and the condition is met
fractal: Anduck: Words are words. No 400Gh miner exists. mircea_popescu stated that one has to be posted to the forums as a confirmed delivery. the only way this bet can be a yes at this point is for someone to lie --
Anduck: i don't really see how one could understand the wording so wrong
fractal: Anduck: thats great -- but thats not what they bet says
fractal: thats not what the bet says -- sorry
Anduck: the customer promised performance is met within the kit
fractal: Anduck: 'Kit" ... not 'KITS' .... they missed performance. punin has admitted it
Anduck: but what i meant is that customer gets the performance he ordered

← | →