mircea_popescu: i guess that's why you don't get a vote then
fractal: jborkl: good point on the botnet -- not sure if thats worse then centralized ASIC mining though.
fractal: kako, a PoW that was most efficient on standard computer hardware would be the best to use, IMO, it would make centralized mining more difficult.
mircea_popescu: basically diff explodes at an exponential rate and somehow people are concern-trolling about how there's not enough parts out or some shit.
jborkl: wasnt there a buttsexcoin?
jborkl: wait, you know there is LTC right?
ThickAsThieves: less than their shipping costs."
ThickAsThieves: "With ASICMINER today announcing blades for as low as 3.5BTC, it appeared that Avalon chips that do not mine today are not going to break even any more. While those blades went already out of stock after some hours, the new price for mining rig is officially set. Essentially this means that if Avalon does not ship the remaining chips fully within the next two weeks, they become worth
fractal: kakobrekla: big miners will lose the vote to small miners who would likely start using a new PoW if it meant they could mine on their own rigs again from parts they buy at the store
mircea_popescu: on the other layer, there's no particular advantage to any one structure of transistors.
mircea_popescu: fractal there's two layers. on one layer, all this is roughly aggitation from a bunch of dishonest people trying to serve the interests of their political masters.
fractal: mircea_popescu: also, Dan Kamisky thinks the SHA algo will be replaced due to centralized mining --- he seems to be a pretty smart guy ;)
mircea_popescu: that's one sad turn of events tbh, they certainly impressed back in the fpga days when they figured out what old chips bfl sanded off to pass as their ip
fractal: gmaxwell said that a tough PoW algo that used all aspects of a general-purpose computer could still probably be sped up by up around 20% on custom hardware --- but that isn't much of a margin to make it worth it until the market cap and mining reward are very high
mircea_popescu: what makes you think i'm not humble when you display the unmitigated audacity to pick numbers ?
fractal: mircea_popescu: I understand that custom hardware could be build for any algo, but my goal would to make it not cost-effective until the coin had a market cap of say $100B
mircea_popescu: fractal there's such a thing as a turing machine
fractal: Thats correct -- my assumption is that the best PoW would be one that performs best in common computer hardware -- using all aspects -- RAM, Memory, and computing power
jborkl: that is just one of the pages, lemme find more
fractal: Am I the only person who thinks that the network will be stronger if the PoW was changed to a algo that couldn't be performed in custom hardware? (i..e gpu's only)
fractal: of course, delayed is just as bad as not shipping at all since if difficulty is too high, the chips are useless ..... but thats another argument
jborkl: you sure, I have seen stuff today that is leading to think they are never coming
fractal: jborkl: then shipped to chineese resellers first, according to rumours , before international orders... thats why people are mad
fractal: jborkl: they're coming, but delayed....
ThickAsThieves: i recall the girl not realizing how many coins AM had actually paid out to shareholders
fractal: hahahah you gotta love mircea_popescu's confidence ;) i actaully love seeing MPOE-PR posts on the forums and the rage replies.... although it will only work as long as he's right about everything ;)
zoinky: because they are billionaires
mircea_popescu: ThickAsThieves because while it could end up realising that power, odds are it won't. judging by the average iq and ability of people involved...
fractal: ThickAsThieves: we're smarter then everyone else. im actually serious.
fractal: mircea_popescu: yes, but the actual impact of it is mostly overblown in americas case.... its mostly a laissez fair keynesian capitalist state
ThickAsThieves: why is the price so low?
fractal: the corporations and the state share the same intrests -- its obvious they would help eachother
gribble: A market order to buy 50000 bitcoins right now would take 8575337.2782 USD and would take the last price up to 300.0000 USD, resulting in an average price of 171.5067 USD/BTC. | Data vintage: 0.0045 seconds
fractal: Basically the NSA government uses large corp's to help them gather information -- nothing that is surprising or out of the ordinary. i dont know why people are shocked at the news. all states , communist, fascist, or otherwise do this
fractal: haha... you've been reading the zerohedge article on assange and schmidt meeting?
ThickAsThieves: more likely to have Amazon or Google coin as a threat than the usacoin
fractal: mircea_popescu: maybe... it will be interesting to see how it plays out in a few years. i predict the US minting virtual currency is a certainty at some point
mircea_popescu: which there isn't, and so bitcoin is soon enough on this score.
mircea_popescu: the only way the state thing could seriously disrupt was if there were only one state.
mircea_popescu: fractal not really. people would keep their savings in btc and buy chinacoin/uscoin/swisscoin as needed
ThickAsThieves: just like the gold stanadrd
ThickAsThieves: but theyd never hold to it
mircea_popescu: actually state sanctioned chains would make bitcoin worth more than the sum of all the chains just on that strength alone
fractal: USACoin would be adopted quickly with government backing, and likely grow to a larger marketcap then BTC
ThickAsThieves: they could never hold to it being deflationary
Scrat: the sheeple might buy it
fractal: ThickAsThieves: although, I see when governments realize what crypto-currency implications are -- they will issue state-sanctioned alt-chains.... this the the only thread to BTC
mircea_popescu: "no" "then stfu and get back in line"
mircea_popescu: "o, we have a mandate fgrom the voters" "well, d othose voters hold any birtcoin ?"
fractal: ThickAsThieves: which makes it even better when you end up being right... your brilliance will shine throughout the ages
fractal: I really think world governments have no clue what is going to hit them in 2-3 years
mircea_popescu: not make a few million. fuckall cares. the idea is that the us president will take office upon swearing an oath to the conclave of bitcoin.
mircea_popescu: we're her to take over the world and reshape it drastically
fractal: not that hard -- we can use Gold as model for BTC -- kings and tyrants were the largest gold holders, and slowly holdings moved
mircea_popescu: they jhave no incentive to, as they already have more fiat than they know what to do with
ThickAsThieves: but theyd need to sell less if price was that high
ThickAsThieves: biggest design flaw in bitcoin: the decimal
mircea_popescu: i would guess group 1 median is somewhere in the 50k range. group 2 median probably about 80-150 btc
mircea_popescu: basically there's a 1-200 people that matter, holding like 90% of all coins. there's ~10k people with modest holdings, doing another 9%
fractal: ThickAsThieves: thats what i've gathered from reading forums -- one guy talked about mining 50K coins and then formatting his HD
mircea_popescu: fractal large holders are part of the float as much as small holders.
fractal: i think less then 5000 people have 1000BTC
fractal: well. around 2-3 million coins have never been moved right? 1 Million is satoshi and 1-2Milion lost -- lets say theres 8M coins in real peoples hands -- 5000 people holding 1000BTC would take up 5M BTC and mean only 3M is left as float
matuszed: Im like 5000 users on there alone
mircea_popescu: prolly 1k gets you in the top 1k for that matter.
mircea_popescu: fractal prolly 1k gets you in the top 5k
fractal: ThickAsThieves: i'm extrapolating for world-wide BTC usage in the future
ThickAsThieves: how many bitcoiners are there with any btc?
fractal: cool.. I think 2,100 is a good goal for someone with a lot of money, and very bullish on bitcoin -- mathmatically no more then 10,000 people can own as much as you, and in reality it will likely be 1000 or less in the future
fractal: I'm just thinking that, if someone wanted to be top 5000 richest BTC in the world, how many would he need to buy right now?
mircea_popescu: there's not that much space, plenty of people own more than 10k
mircea_popescu: someone should send the labcoiners a digest list of glbse muppets hating mp back in like... august 2012.
ThickAsThieves: "and just for the record, I think he's really good at running an exchange that has no securities."
ThickAsThieves: re labcoiners hating mp "I agree 100%. Right after his little post I thought "wow, didn't he show this same distaste towards asicminer at one point?" This was the biggest signal for me, and I bought up a shitload.. "
fractal: It's likely , but not certain, that people who stole large amounts of bitcoins will try to launder them before cashing out on MTGOX.
fractal: the 200BTC was returned to this address --> https://blockchain.info/address/12HUyZeNFqk4db2EM7GY5e6homTVTpPd7Z
fractal: ThickAsThieves: the ownder has over 10,000 BTC -- likely a criminal/money launderer -- friedcat sohuld have kept it, he has a responsibility to shareholders
kleeck: FC returned the tx fee, instead of keeping it.
Anduck: mircea_popescu: there's nothing to comment in that pastebin. it's all just facts and how the bet is
mircea_popescu: ppl will want to comment on the pastebin lol
Anduck: mircea_popescu: i just want the bet to be resolved correctly :)
thestringpuller: the optiins and diff market are very open
mircea_popescu: the thing is i know what doesn't work, i don't need to experiment to discover what's wrong with boiler rooms, wash trading, pump and dumps or all the rest of the "internet investment" stuff.
fractal: mircea_popescu: i've always thought that becoming my own competition is the best way to provide the most efficient service to a market...
mircea_popescu: because the goal is to make bitcoin work, not to try and finesse a few coins out of the masses.
fractal: mircea_popescu: why not start a btct.co type site using your backend code? ;) you can own the small-fish market and big-fish
mircea_popescu: ifg they're smart.
mircea_popescu: significant competition would participate in the same market, face the same constraints and take the same measures,
fractal: mircea_popescu: if significant competition comes around would you adjust to the market?
mircea_popescu: if random chinese asic manufacturers would help rather than hinder we'd be moving a lot faster, but even so, we're moving.
mircea_popescu: this is deliberate, helping the community professionalize.
mircea_popescu: fractal there's brokers doing exactly that.
mircea_popescu: Rulother coinbr.com you mean ?
Rulother: There's a service out there, that will do the trading for you with a small % per transaction. Forgot the name :P
mircea_popescu: i've said it's only going to go up in the future, and it's a fact.
mircea_popescu: the fee was originally 0, for people who wanted to beta. it went up from 20 to 30 when glbse failed.
mircea_popescu: bujt nothing like the whale.
fractal: I made an investment a couple weeks ago,,, profit seems to have stalled there for a bit
fractal: nice... you must have done well... they need a few more whales to play to get the profit up to 1% tho... can't belive 1 guy took them for 4000BTC
mircea_popescu: there;s anarticle on trilema discussing it somewhere, remind me to link you sometime
mircea_popescu: fractal i was one of the large early investors.
fractal: although the investment ROI has stalled in the past couple weeks... but i think whoehver bought SD madea mistake ;)
mircea_popescu: "please agree X is a great company to spare me the emoptional cost of readjusting with a contrary and grossly dissinterested reality"
Rulother: I'm going to automatically ignore anyone that says that on the forums
ThickAsThieves: they do
mircea_popescu: rather than this underhanded bs. does anyone actually imagine it works ?!
mircea_popescu: i wouldn't want to miss up on the next cher.
ThickAsThieves: dont bother
mircea_popescu: Swift moved to Nashville, Tennessee at the age of fourteen to pursue a career in country music.
Rulother: Well she just consumes souls and then writes about it and makes money
mircea_popescu: what, skin them, fill the husk with hay and reannimate it with the dark arts of necromancy ?
ThickAsThieves: why are people surprised, isnt this the Madonna/Cher/Britney formula?
mircea_popescu: ThickAsThieves i think it died once fractal said the magical word i agree
mircea_popescu: just saying that the definitions of words aren't at all that pinned down as we like to think them
mircea_popescu: anyway, niot saying the laptop example controls
ThickAsThieves: wanna start another?
Anduck: Rulother: yes
Rulother: So there's like two arguements going on at once in here I see
fractal: mircea_popescu: right -- i meants the 2nd laptop comes with a power cord also
mircea_popescu: but you can't really run the laptop w/o power except for two hours
fractal: mircea_popescu: So, 1 UNIT would be what was required to operate the original laptop at advertised specs.... if the company sent you a 2nd laptop to make up for the fact that your first laptop wasn't good enough -- you received 2 UNITS
mircea_popescu: ThickAsThieves not sure why they're that aggitated anyway.
ThickAsThieves: mp Pale Phoenix really doesnt like you (labcoin thread) "Perhaps I should be more tolerant of manic, shrill bullies like PRBot. It must be quite tragic to be so sure that you stand at the center of the universe, only to realize that you're just another decaying bit of yesterday's news."
fractal: mircea_popescu: depends what your definition of unit is, i suppose.... i think most people would say its one unit.... but if there were 2 laptops, because the first laptop wasn't fast enough, it would be 2 units
fractal: jurov: thats totally wrong. thats like saying a BFL single is a UNIT if they ship 2 to make up for it
fractal: Anduck: No, its not. The unit missed performance numbers
mircea_popescu: fractal what about the power brick ?
Anduck: fractal: the unit is hashing at 400 ghash. the unit has more h-boards that was told at the site (when they ordered) but that doesn't change the performance of the ordered unit
mircea_popescu: i sort-of wonder if after this people will go have some nice icecream and argue over the cones with the poor hapless waitress.
fractal: Anduck: and that unit is hashing at 380Gh... if they send some more hardware, it doesn't change the fact that the 400Gh unit is only 380Gh.
mircea_popescu: bobbabad_ it's not a comeback. it's an attempt to help you start on the work of self-education. do try and answer the question, it's important.
ozbot: Bitfury 400 GH/s Bitcoin Mining Rig Hits US Shores - The Genesis Block
fractal: http://thegenesisblock.com/bitfury-400-ghs-bitcoin-mining-rig-hits-us-shores/ this is a UNIT -- any more hardware is just making up for it missing performance hashrate numbers
bobbabad_: haha, nice comeback... It fascinates to try to understand the underlieing motivation of self destruction
Anduck: they didnt send more units
Anduck: the unit that a customer has bought
fractal: thats why they're shipping more hardware
Anduck: Bunnyh: the bet was about advertised performance, not about advertised hardware amount
jurov: Anduck, they did not even ship 400gh unit/order/whatever. problem solved
Bunnyh: fractal: if the yes/no decision comes to that issue, it will be a really tough call
mircea_popescu: but that's the problem bitbet is resolving. slowly and verbosely.
mircea_popescu: most intellectual spaces have what's called "Terms of art" to come to terms with the problem
fractal: Bunnyh: right -- they're getting more , but the actual hardware itself missed specs -- this is what i based my NO bet on
mircea_popescu: ThickAsThieves it's a problem this, getting language to work for the purpose of communication in a novel space.
bobbabad_: mircea_popescu: I get you the two of you like to cause drama and stir the pot... but with posts like that you both just looks like assclowns
Bunnyh: fractal: i don't really have a good opinion on how to decide, if they did deliver 400GH for everyone who ordered 400GH, and the total hardware doesn't consume more power than advertised (but would consist of more than 1 master board with 16 hashing boards)
Anduck: and 5 orders delivered.. it should be a yes,then
ThickAsThieves: i missed this whole argument, but i say, when shit is this hard to sort, you are solving the wrong problem
kleeck: Are we just saying the same thing over and over, guys?
Anduck: thats the bet¨
Anduck: they ship what people ordered
Anduck: jurov: but thats not really part of the bet
Anduck: mircea_popescu: what's your opinion about the "5 delivered orders"
fractal: Bunnyh: if the 400Gh doesn't actaully hit 400Gh, would you say that the unit did not meet performance ? (Then , if the company was nice and sent a refund, or more hardware, would it change the fact that the 400Gh unit didn't hit performance hashrate" ?
bobbabad_: mircea_popescu: you both seem to enjoy the occational rant but posts like this https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=263445.msg3036369#msg3036369
mircea_popescu: ThickAsThieves receipt is the measure of delivery :D
mircea_popescu: dude, the may bfl delivery bet took what, two weeks ?
jurov: at least i did not mix shipping and delivery there
Anduck: jurov: the "will ship their 25ghash and 400gash units in time".. if there wasn't any 400 ghash units ordered in the first orders... but it's been proven that it can be built (why wouldn't it be possible? just attach the cards) and it will meet the spec
jurov: http://bitbet.us/bet/472/kncminer-will-deliver-asic-devices-before-october-1st/ << this will be interesting then, too
ThickAsThieves: but oh bitching when they resolve...
ThickAsThieves: i like the concept
mod6: i like her, she delivers butthurt to the bitcoin masses
ThickAsThieves: gotta have a place for the hamburgers!
mircea_popescu: i doubt they give a shit.
fractal: mircea_popescu: maybe the deciders will read these logs and the conversation on the page and be influenced
Anduck: it's been proven that a mining card does meet the advertised performance..
mircea_popescu: fractal he has no involvement in the decision of it tho, so why shouildn't he argue it ?
Anduck: mircea_popescu: yeah, true. but that the bet shouldnt be failed due that.. they're all same modular cards that the mining unit is built from
fractal: mircea_popescu: which I think would make it a conflict of intrest for him to debate it -- I think 3rd parties who are neutral should strictly look at the language -- otherwise he can just say 'oh, thats not what i meant!' and fuck over the NO bets ;(
Bunnyh: i see 3 requirements: a) they must ship both kinds of devices (25G and 400G) before 1st. b) both kinds of devices must meet power/speed requirements. c) 5 deliveries confirmed (this req. doesn't specify which kind of devices)
mircea_popescu: they know wtf is going on, don't include 400gh if they have no orders to ship for 400gh etc
mircea_popescu: well you know it's always good policy to get the manufacturer to write the bet, even if you want to bet on yes.
Anduck: i bet the 10 btc
fractal: Anduck: Honestly, it seems to me like you wrote a vague bet, that other people have read totally differently, and you're trying to change 'what you meant' .... its not fair man, seriously.
jurov: obviously the delivery and shipping should be subject to same conditions
Anduck: which in my eyes doesn't really need both of the mining units shipped
Anduck: the delivery is about 5 units, shipping is about 25gh and 400gh..
jurov: "will ship their 25 and 400" << it's AND not OR
fractal: there needs to be at least 1 400Gh UNIT hashing as advertised -- and if they miss performance, sending more UNITS doesn't count
Anduck: the 25gh kit and 400gh kit are built from same modular units
mircea_popescu: jborkl re the wording : any time one sees a badly worded bet they can make a better worded one, which at least theoretically would create an advantage for his bet over the old bet and people would flock there.
Anduck: and i think that is met if there are 5 confirmed deliveries
fractal: Common man!! the bet specifically says "Delivered"
ThickAsThieves: "Further to the above, TradeFortress has announced that Coinlenders is closing - and that the current site is only a demo, but one which has the same functionality as a real site would (a similarish approach to BTC-TC's "it's just a game" stance - though actually a worse one from an investor's perspective)."
Anduck: they can ship 400gh.. it's built from same m-boards and h-boards.
fractal: Forget about the 400Gh being shipped -- the issue is what defines a 'UNIT' as advertised and meeting performance specs
mircea_popescu: jurov it'd be fucking crazy tho. what, they sold like 9 boards to 5 ppl ?
jborkl: well, then we have our answer
mircea_popescu: somehow, somewhere. else the bet is only half satisfied
mircea_popescu: jborkl the rationale is that since there's an A and a B in the bet, and 5 proofs, you want those 5 proofs rto include both A and B
mircea_popescu: just one of them things.
BigBitz: What is the bet?
mircea_popescu: fractal pretty much the only way it works, make your bet neutral.
Anduck: and it works = meets the adverticed performance. it's been proven earlier
fractal: mircea_popescu: so you suggest cancelling bet buy betting on the other side ... the weight is too low though ;) i dont have enough BTC ;(
jborkl: the bet does not specify which 5 devices
Anduck: mircea_popescu: true. but we don't know was the first orders (that were shipped this week) including a 400gh miner. but it's proven that it does work if one actually bought one
jurov: regardless whether it can be built out of smaller ones
mircea_popescu: it'd be pretty crazy if nobody bought a 400 then
jurov: as i said if no 400gh order was delivered, and we require at least one, then the bit was not filled
Anduck: mircea_popescu: there is an example of 400 ghash unit but it was a demo, not delivered unit. but that can be delivered if anyone bought it. it's the same m-boards and h-boards.. just enough of them to make the hashrate of 400gh
mircea_popescu: what were the 25 selling for ?
fractal: mircea_popescu: i'm reading the bet cancellation policy link now... thanks
mircea_popescu: jborkl how much was the 400 ? like 150 btc or something ?
fractal: the problem here I think is what is a 'UNIT' --- this is what we're debating ;)
Anduck: i think the 5x 25gh would be sufficient too (but my opinion must be non-counting due to the fact i am on "yes" side of the bet)