fractal: Anduck: The fact is that people betting on bitbet.us can ONLY go by what the language of the bet says --- The bet says a 400Gh miner, as advertised, must be 400Gh.... The advertised Miner was -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- it is onlt 365Gh.
Anduck: the unit changed from 1 m-board filled with 16 h-cards to 2 m-boards with 19 h-cards. so they failed this.. but the UNIT does as performed
fractal: Which means the bet is a no. they shipped more because they missed on performance. its the same as a refund.
Anduck: but thats not part of the goddamn bet
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the bet says. the bet says a 400Gh miner, as advertised -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- must be at least 400Gh -- it is not.
pankkake: kakobrekla: I'm waiting for the TAT PT
Anduck: bitfurystrikesback says 400gh kit (same as 400 gh unit as we accepted) will deliver 400gh at <400W. this was met. the chip count though was changed from 256 to more.
fractal: the 400Gh UNIT as advertised -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- must be at least 400Gh -- it is not.
fractal: That's a picture of the kit/unit. it doeesn't do 400Gh....
fractal: You are now disagreeing with thegensisblock also
fractal: Anduck: proof that the 400Gh kit is what I describe --- http://thegenesisblock.com/bitfury-400-ghs-bitcoin-mining-rig-hits-us-shores/
Anduck: the chip itself is awesome
Anduck: and i get a 400gh unit and it does the 400gh? chip count changed, yes
Anduck: at bfsb boards they do max 1,5
fractal: Anduck: the performance was not met. It is only 365Gh.
Anduck: the chips can be run at >3 GH
fractal: The bet says the 400Gh UNIT as advertised -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- must be at least 400Gh -- it is not.
mircea_popescu: incidentally, is this bitfury pcb stuff pretty much the most open/modder friendly asic miner to date ?
Anduck: the kit does 400gh
Anduck: 400gh kit does 400gh, thats what the bet says
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the bet says.
fractal: pankkake: Hashrate for the 400Gh kit/unit as defined by the hardware, as advertsied , was not met.
gribble: You are now authenticated for user mircea_popescu with key 8A736F0E2FB7B452
fractal: pankkake: They did not meet ADVERTISED performance.
Anduck: it says 25gh unit and 400gh unit - bfsb sold 25gh kit and 400gh kit. so you can pretty much make the assumption that kit=unit there,right?
tyrion70: so anducks definition of a unit being "whats in the box"
tyrion70: but there is no such thing as a unit...
tyrion70: the bet describes a unit..
fractal: pankkake: well, its a no, if you read the bet language.
Anduck: the bet required the unit to produce 400gh at <400W. it does that, even though it does that with more chips than announced
pankkake: but the bet does not mention chips or boards or whatever
pankkake: honestly, I think it should resolve as yes then
fractal: pankkake: 400Gh miner -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- as advertised -- which is what was required by the bet -- only does 365Gh
Anduck: and the unit does >400 gigahashes, too
tyrion70: depending on the perspective..
fractal: pankkake: yes. But thats not what the bet says.
pankkake: don't care about the nubem of chips
fractal: Anduck: The HW promise IS the performance promise! Imagine if you are running a server farm, and Intel says --- "oh, sorry, our chips aren't fast enough --, but heres 1000 extra servers. Oh, you can't fit them in your datacenter because you ran out of space? too bad!!"
pankkake: regardless of number of chips, which aren't in the bet
Anduck: the kit makes 400gh and includes more than 256 chips.
fractal: There are 2 metrics for performance. -- hashrate, and Wattage. It has to meet BOTH.
Anduck: the site says kit makes 400gh and includes 256 chips
tyrion70: but can you at least imagine that ppl bet on 256 chips doing 400 gh based on the information from the bet
Anduck: so they only broke the promise of hardware amount, they couldn't make the 400gh unit out of 1 m-board only
Anduck: if they added GPU's, it would break the performance promise since it would eat more than 400 wattas
Anduck: one looks that yeah they can't make 256 produce 400gh at <400W. but if 256 chips don't make 400gh, it isn't a 400gh unit, right?
fractal: Anduck: tyrion is saying that the bet can be viewed from a 'customer' perspective or a 'technical' perspective.... depending on which one, the bet can be a yes or no.
tyrion70: and that statement "could be" covered by the original bid text..
fractal: 'No way they can get 400GH out of 256 chips'
tyrion70: both based on the same initial bet text..
tyrion70: being: no way they get 400GH out of 256 chips..
Anduck: but it didn't alter the advertised performance (400gh at <400w)
Anduck: but the kit ended up to have more m-boards and h-boards than promised
Anduck: the kit was advertised to make 400gh at <400W. and it was also advertised to have 1 m-board and 16 h-boards
tyrion70: can't be both at the same time..
Anduck: it made it with a different hardware amount than promised. but that wasn't partt of the bet
fractal: it's very clear http://www.bitfurystrikesback.com/product/400gh-miner-october-2013/ -- 400Gh miner -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- as advertised -- the hardware did not perform as advertised. The bet clearly states that the hardware must perform as advertised. All conditions of the bet were not met.
tyrion70: anduck, it was at the site wasn't it?
fractal: tyrion70: I think its clear the bet language is not great. it its cancelled, i would understand, but I think it comes down to what most people would interpret a 'UNIT as Advertised' as being...
Anduck: they failed to ship the kit as described, though the kit does deliver the performance as promised. nobody can say that unit = 1 m-board + 16 h-boards, that wasnt ever defined anywhere!!!
tyrion70: it has nothing to do with meeting the performance yet..
tyrion70: ok u agree there can be two definitions of unit?
Anduck: so you can -assume_ it means the kit when talking about unit
tyrion70: I could have read on the website that if I ordered a kit I would get 1 m board with 16 boards..
Anduck: the website only declares that a kit is 1 m-board + 16 h-boards
tyrion70: both of which come from the same website..
tyrion70: apparently there are two ways of looking at a unit..
tyrion70: it leaves that to the reader..
tyrion70: unit is not further explained..
tyrion70: in the bet text itself
Anduck: only the 400gh kit is declared
tyrion70: there we go..
Anduck: isn't the assumption of 1 unit = 1 m-board + 16 h-board wrong too? it's never declared anywhere
tyrion70: the question is not are you wrong..
Anduck: then kit=unit=order
fractal: thats exactly how I interpreted it -- based on the bet language -- thats all I have to go by... The site doesn't say "message Anduck" if you have any questions.
Anduck: well if he got that thing from the kit declaration
Anduck: bfsb.com says that the kit is that
tyrion70: there is a difference..
tyrion70: the thing is..
tyrion70: well.. you read and interpreted the word unit as order or kit
Anduck: the 400gh or 25gh thing you can order from bfsb.com
Anduck: + the unit must do more than 400 GH
tyrion70: skip the W ;)
Anduck: but that's what the performance means, right?
Anduck: performance is W/GH AND the hashrate
fractal: Anduck: "400gh unit 400W" means that the unit must be BOTH more then 400Gh, and less then 400W... no mention of Gh/W ratio was made.
Anduck: but the performance isn't same as hashrate
tyrion70: but if the bet says: an order at advertized performance (400GH)
Anduck: the bet says "400gh unit at 400W" ? *
tyrion70: now if the bet says: a jupiter at advertized performance (400GH) the bet would be NO right?
fractal: Anduck: Thats irrelevant, as thats not what the bet says.
Anduck: but the 400gh unit ended up to be 2 m-boards + 19 h-boards. so they fucking failed that hardware amount promise, RIGHT???? but the 400gh unit (which has now changed to 2 m-boards instead of 1) they ordered performs as promised
fractal: Again, Anduck, Thats not what the bet says....
fractal: No, its not. The 400Gh unit , as advertised "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips", is only 365Gh
Anduck: but the performance is still correct!
fractal: Anduck: The BET says 'as advertised'
Anduck: the unit is MORE than 1 m-board with 16 h-boards!!!
tyrion70: there is no bitfury "unit" therefore ppl betting might have different opinions on what a unit is..
fractal: Anduck: YES, but thats not what the bet says !!
tyrion70: bet language was not clear (should have used the exact language from bitfury)
tyrion70: but the bet says: 400 GH/s unit 400W while it does 400 GH/s 2 units 400W
fractal: The website says it. ""1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips",
Anduck: who the fuck says 1 m-board with 16 h-boards is 1 unit?
Anduck: who the fuck says 1 m-board is 1 unit?
fractal: 2 units is 2 units. because they missed performance.
fractal: For the record -- nobody who ordered a 400Gh OR LESS has reported receiving more then 1 M-board.
Anduck: but those hardware as the unit would still perform as promised
tyrion70: which would make me very happy customer nonetheless...
Anduck: so they failed that promise
Anduck: it's a single 400gh unit you buy. you get the 400gh (even though it's splitted in 2 mainboards and 19 h-boards)
tyrion70: like I said if I opened the box today one could argue that I have received two units instead of one..
tyrion70: because 2 units makes the bet a no..
Anduck: even though the miner size or color or amount of modular units has changed
tyrion70: it means that the text is ambivalent..
fractal: 1 master board is therefore assumed to be a UNIT
tyrion70: depening on "my understanding" of the word unit...
fractal: Anduck: The bet language says UNIT. The website says "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips",
Anduck: thats not in the bet. the bet refers to the bfsb.com shop declared performance of 400gh unit. and it's in the parenthesis too
tyrion70: anduck: do you agree that if I ordered a 400 GH Kit from bitfury and I openend the box I would see two "units"
tyrion70: anduck; do you agree that I should not have to read another website to bet?
Anduck: they said that the kit will include 1 m-board and 16 h-boards. but it ended up including 2 m-boards with 19 h-boards
fractal: Anduck: yes, but thats not what the bet says.
Anduck: it doesn't matter that does the miner change color or what sized it is... the thing is that they had to deliver the advertised performance. performance means X amount of GHash at Y W/GH.
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the bet says.
Anduck: so they cant ship for example GPU's
Anduck: and it must meet the W/GH
Anduck: the bet requires that bfsb ships 400 gh to people who ordered 400gh
tyrion70: both anduck and fractal, try not to convince eachother of your own opinion but see if you can fit both opinions in the same bet..
Anduck: fractal: what is the unit?
fractal: The UNIT, as advertised, didn't perform as promised .
Anduck: or the SIZE
fractal: So, how do you expect people to read the bet, -- AS adveritsed -- ?? and then tell them later 'Sorry, it doesn't matter if that was as advertised'
Anduck: but as long as it performs as promised, the bet is yes
Anduck: the kit
Anduck: o well there is
Anduck: but there's no declaration for 400gh unit to be 1 m-board with 16 h-boards
fractal: Anduck: the bet says nothing about keeping promises and shipping more hardware if they miss performance numebrs, it simply says that the 400Gh unit, as advertised "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips", must be 400Gh... IT was not.
Anduck: nor did the 25gh
Anduck: but the 400gh unit did nopt
fractal: It's like BFL shipping 2 singles because 1 was only 1/2 the hashrate
fractal: Anduck: And thats what was advertsied -- according to the bet language -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
Anduck: but the performance did not
Anduck: but the kit hardware amount changed
Anduck: fractal: that was meant to be the 400gh kit. it was meant that 400gh kit only includes 1 m-board filled with h-boards
Anduck: tyrion70: no, for the 400gh unit
fractal: You can't write a bet and they say "oh, I actually meant this" later
fractal: Anduck: thats not what the bet says.
Anduck: the only declaration for 400gh unit i can think of is that what they sell at the site. the 400 gh KIT is what they sell
tyrion70: anduck what's the power usage on that thing anyway?
Anduck: and i think it was quite clear to understand that 25gh unit and 400gh unit meant the thing you can buy from the website. and the thing you can buy from the website is kit
fractal: Anduck: IT doesn't matter what you say now.... THE BET LANGUAGE IS ALL THAT MATTERS
Anduck: the bet wasn't about what the full kit is, it was about that the full kit will deliver the performance
fractal: Well, the FULL KIT is STILL "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
fractal: Anduck: KIT is nowhere in the bet language. It means something different to UNIT. sorry.
Anduck: the KIT now happened to include more m-boards than it advertised but the PERFORMANCE is still as promised!!!!!!!!
fractal: we are talking about UNITS, as per the bet language.
fractal: 'KIT" is nowhere in the bet language. stop using it. thank you.
Anduck: no mention about units in there
Anduck: the 400gh KIT was advertised as taht
fractal: Anduck: The 400Gh unit, as advertised, is "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
Anduck: but people got the promised performance?
fractal: The best doesnt say "If they miss performance targets, they can ship multiple units to make up for it"
Anduck: so that when they advertised that 400gh kit will do 400 gigahashes at <400W.. it is met
fractal: Anduck: Thats not what the bet says.
Anduck: fractal: indeed. so one must have understood that when talking about 400gh unit it means the 400gh KIT you can order from the site
fractal: No it doesn't. Performance means Hashrate and Wattage seperatly... No Proportion was mentioned in the bet language.
Anduck: fractal: they were sold as kits
fractal: Anduck: why do you keep using the word KIT? KIT is not in the bet langugage at all. KIT is irrelevant
tyrion70: Someone could have thought: No way they get that GH/W out of one chip: I'm betting no
Anduck: they did not fail the promised/advertised PERFORMANCE of the kit (and the bet was about the performance only)
Anduck: so in my eyes they failed the _hardware amount promise_ , they had to deliver more of those modular cards to make the 400gh kit
tyrion70: ok.. now I get the complete picture..
Anduck: a full m-board _should_ make 400gh and now actually only does 370 gh. but the unit/kit, which people ordered, does 400gh (so it includes 2 m-boards and 18-20 h-boards)
fractal: tyrion70: They are not .
fractal: Anduck: no, its not. As per the website - the 400Gh unit -- as advertised -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips"
Anduck: tyrion70: the 400gh kit itself is built from m-boards and h-boards
fractal: The bet says the 400Gh unit -- as advertised -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" must be 400Gh. IT ISN'T
fractal: Anduck: I agree with you. but thats not what the bet says
Anduck: and they do ship
fractal: You won't see anyone with 400Gh only getting delivered -- because BSB would have to ship them 2 M-boards, 2 R-pi's, etc.
Anduck: the ordered 400gh unit and 25gh unit.
fractal: tyrion70: Nobody who ordered a 400Gh unit has posted recieving more then 400Gh.... so I can't answer that question.
tyrion70: lets take another example..
Anduck: but the people who ordered 400gh unit got >400gh at promised watts?
fractal: therefore it missed performance targets
fractal: tyrion: Exactly, the 400Gh unit was only 365Gh .
Anduck: well the bet describes what means "advertised performance"
fractal: tyrion70: yes. And the 400Gh unit -- as advertised -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- did not meet performance targets
fractal: Then 'as advertised' would make it a bad bet... and it wouldn't have been accepted.
Anduck: the bet says: 25gh unit and 400gh unit must meet the advertised performance. they promise 400gh at 400W for the 400gh unit at bfsb.com. that is met. what's so weird about this?
fractal: And the 400Gh unit -- as advertised -- "1 Master board 16 hashing boards with 16 Bitfury 55nm ASIC chips for total of 256 chips" -- did not meet performance targets
tyrion70: fractal: the bet doesn't say "as advertised on the website www.blabla" .. the bet specifies the exact conditions itself.. without a need to read some website..
fractal: Anduck: Unforunately, thats not what the bet says.
Anduck: and they failed that but the overall performance of the whole 400gh unit/kit is as advertised
FabianB_: hmm.. i bet the bitfury argument loop will still last a few hours..